What's Hot? | My Favorites | Paparazzi | Columns | La Negra | Tourist | Mini-Stop | E-Mail | Credits
a movie review
The Pianist is based on the memoirs of Polish musician Wladyslaw Szpilman, who survived the Warsaw ghetto, and it’s Roman Polanski’s strongest and most personally felt movie. This should not come as a great surprise, since as a child Polanski survived the Kraków ghetto and lost family members in the Holocaust. The real surprise is that the horrors on display in The Pianist are presented matter-of-factly -- which of course makes them seem even more horrific. We are not accustomed to such reserve in a movie about the Holocaust, and especially not in a Polanski movie, where the violence has often been close to Grand Guignol. But in this film he is trying to be devastatingly true to his emotions, and so there is no need for hyperbole. At times, the tension between the unwavering directness of his technique and the anguish that is behind it is almost unbearable. When we see a Nazi soldier casually shoot a Jewish girl in the head for asking an innocent question, or when we see soldiers throw an old man in a wheelchair over a balcony, we are staring into an everyday inferno.
Szpilman, who is played with feral grace by Adrien Brody, survived it: Alone among his family, he managed to escape from the ghetto and hide out in Warsaw until the war’s end. We first see him in 1939, not quite 30, playing Chopin during a radio broadcast interrupted by German bombing. At the end, we see him playing the same nocturne in a concert hall that had once been shelled. It’s as if his story had come full circle, except that he is crying now and savoring each note the way he savored each morsel of food in captivity. Halfway through the movie, there’s a great, brief scene where Szpilman is hidden away in a Warsaw apartment and unable to touch its piano for fear of alerting the neighbors to his presence. The silent agony that ensues is one of the most powerful expressions of spiritual denial I’ve ever seen in a film. Szpilman’s artistry is not sentimentalized; we are never made to feel that he stayed alive because of it. Mostly he survived on luck and gumption. But Polanski recognizes the soul-deep power that music held for Szpilman, and his playing in the end is both an anthem of renewal and a lament.
Polanski doesn’t sentimentalize the Jews, either. The Jewish police employed by the Germans in the ghetto are shown to be almost as ruthless as their overseers, and some of the underground operatives turn out to be scoundrels. In his memoir, which was published in 1946 under the title Death of a City and soon banned by the Communists, Szpilman wrote that his experience shattered his belief in the “solidarity of the Jews.” No doubt some people will regard the divulging of that experience as a betrayal, but Polanski honors the Jews of Warsaw by not romanticizing them; besides, there are many acts of extraordinary generosity and courage in The Pianist. They are just as inexplicable as the depravities.
Although he engages in some minor arms smuggling, Szpilman himself is not especially brave or virtuous. He is not the kind of conventional hero -- or anti-hero, for that matter -- a movie such as this would seem to require. He’s a watcher, a reactor, and yet his recessiveness has metaphorical power: Szpilman is like a wraith witnessing the ruin of his beloved city and its people. (The Pianist is, among others things, a eulogy for Warsaw.) When he is finally driven out of his hiding places and wanders the blasted streets, the imagery goes beyond starkness into the surreal -- we might be looking at a lunar landscape by De Chirico.
The most remarkable aspect of Szpilman’s memoir is that it was written so close to the time of the events described and yet is full of poise and equanimity. There is no ache for revenge in his book, and there is none in Polanski’s film, either. Szpilman lived out his days in Poland as a celebrated pianist and composer of popular songs and children’s music, dying in 2000. Polanski, whose notorious and harrowing life is well known, had not, until this movie, filmed in Poland in 40 years. And yet these two men, who might appear from their lives and works to be temperamentally unalike, share a distaste for special pleading or bathos. In The Pianist, suffering is seen with such clarity that its relief becomes a balm of the greatest magnitude. It’s the relief we get when Szpilman plays the piano again, or merely makes it through another day. In moments like these, we are confronted with the significance, the momentousness, of the ordinary. (1 hr. 48 mins.; PG-13) — PETER RAINER
Spotlight: Adrien Brody
"I felt the impact of everything on me," says Adrien Brody of his role in Roman Polanski's The Pianist, the director's first film to address World War II. The picture was partially shot in Poland, and is set in the Warsaw Ghetto -- a place much like the ghetto Polanski himself survived and his mother did not. Based on the Polish piano star Wladyslaw Szpilman's autobiography, the film required a tremendous commitment from its lead. "I felt the importance of what this film means. It was grueling," Brody says of a role that required him to learn Polish and German, lose 30 pounds, and learn how to play classical piano. "But it was also extremely powerful. I felt honored that Roman cast me." Brody plays much of the film without actors, alone among horrifically realistic re-creations of the bombed-out ghetto. "I cried when I shot my first scene," the 29-year-old says. Still bone-thin, the New York native calls the experience a real turning point in his life. "I tried to experience a taste of the deprivation they felt. I owed it to Szpilman, and I owed it to Roman as well."
An Asian Ascension
The orient has always been where the sun sets.
Failures and deceits are likely to happen in this part of the world.
Destitution and Emotions are the themes of the region.
Five sunsets ago, a beauty stood firm.
Colored people won the hearts.
A jewel of Asia nearly clinched;
the crown of the universe.
White beauties gave different reactions;
To this turn around of results.
Clamming up is no jape;
Shame is not the word;
Standing is the ultimate reward.
A beauty from the East.
Made available to the hearts of the universe.
A year of sparing and digging.
A woman never to have a child.
Diamonds and gold are gifts to treasure.
The heat of summer glistened;
as a fish flies towards the sky.
To rule this part of the planet.
To deliver the message of tommorow.
A nice soul to remember.
@copyrighted. All Rights Reserved. No portion may be copied or reproduced in books, pamphlets, outlines or notes, whether printed,
mimeographed, typewritten, copied in different electronic devices or in any other form, for distribution or sale, without the written permission of the author.
@An Asian Ascencion published 02.08.03